Hi everyone,
I try to simulate a problem similar to the binflow tutorial, i.e. I have a dense particle flow (quasi-static regime) with a high number of particles, permanent particle contacts and very low velocities. During my simulations I have experienced oscillations when particles are discharged at the bottom and others are fed in at the top.
I tried to find some references in the literature and I have found "Luding et al - Anomalous energy dissipation in molecular-dynamics simulations of grains: The 'detachment' effect". They say that for many particles in contact with each other the viscous disspation through particle contact is inefficient for long-wavelength modes.
Luding suggests in "Introduction to Discrete Element Methods" to indroduce an additional (velocity dependent) "Background friction". In LIGGGHTS this could be achieved through the "fix viscous" command. But I have found that the damping has to be rather large to damp the occuring oscillations and therefore could influence the solid flow.
Therefore I wanted to consult the LIGGGHTS community, maybe someone has faced similar problems and found a better solution and would like to discuss it here.
Best regards
Harald
richti83 | Sat, 01/02/2016 - 14:14
rollingfriction model ?
What rolling friction modell did you choose ? It is known that a type A rf-modell (named cdt in liggghts) leads to an oscillation.
See "Rahmann, M.; Katterfeld, Andre; Schott, Dingena L.; Lodewijks, Gabril Influence of the software on the calibration process of DEM simulations" Fig. 11 for example.
hunger | Sat, 01/02/2016 - 19:35
I have chosen the ctd model
I have chosen the ctd model in LIGGGHTS. Thanks for the hint, I did not consider this so far.
I read a little bit more about the rolling friction models and I have also found nice information about the oscillations in quasi-static simulations of Model Type A in "Jun Ai, Jian-Fei Chen, J. Michael Rotter, Jin Y. Ooi: Assessment of rolling resistance models in discrete element simulations".
I will try the EPSD/EPSD2 model, thanks a lot for the hint!!