Forums
Dear LIGGGHTS users,
I would like to use the rolling friction model "epsd" for my simulations of nanoparticles and I would prefer having a damping term also above the full mobilisation torque M_rm. Is there a scientific reason for the damping to be neglected at full mobilisation (f = 0)? I can't find any in the underlying publication "Jun Ai, Jian-Fei Chen, J. Michael Rotter, Jin Y. Ooi, Powder Technology, 206 (3), p 269-282 (2011)". Or is this just due to the implementation? Because then I would simply copy the respective part in the "rolling_model_epsd.h" file and recompile to achieve rolling damping also above full mobilisation.
Best wishes
Jens
good question
Hi Jens!
To be honest I do not remember a special reason, but at least I wrote a comment in the code, so I had probably a reason for doing so. I will check the reference this week and come back to this threat.
Maybe it is just a bug.
Bests
Andreas
Hi Andreas,
Hi Andreas,
thanks a lot for your reply! After going again through the reference, I can safely state that in the reference the damping was only neglected at full mobilization to enable better comparability between different rolling-friction models. The authors state several times (section 5.3, p. 274 and section 7.4, p. 279 ) that the coefficient f can be chosen differently to achieve higher viscous effects.
I guess that you implemented the model as is to avoid another coefficient to be chosen by the user.
Best wishes
Jens
Thanks
Hi Jens!
Thanks for your effort. You are right, I implemented it as is. Therefore, I choose f as 0.
Cheers
Andreas