| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| file.vtk_.tar_.gz | 31.78 KB |
Hi Chris,
as the command "region ID mest/tet xx.vtk ..." needs a volume legacy VTK file. What I am really confused is that, what is a real legacy vtk mesh that LIGGGHTS supports? And how to make/convert STL mesh to this type of mesh?
Importing STL file into paraview, and save as Legacy VTK, but it is
# vtk DataFile Version 3.0
and using gmsh -2 xxx.stl -o xxx.vtk, it's
# vtk DataFile Version 2.0.
region inReg mesh/tet file file.vtk scale 1 move 0. 0. 0. rotate 0. 0. 0. units box
-------------------
......
Note: Skipping empty line in VTK mesh file
Note: Skipping empty line in VTK mesh file
Note: Skipping empty line in VTK mesh file
WARNING: VTK file contains other types than tetrahedra - only tets are currently supported in LIGGGHTS, other cells are discarded (input_mesh_tet.cpp:276)
Setting up run ...
INFO: Resetting random generator for region inReg
ERROR: Unable to calculate region volume. Possible sources of error:
(a) region volume is too small or out of domain
(b) particles for insertion are too large when using all_in yes
(c) region is 2d, but should be 3d (region.cpp:600)
........
---------------------
The vtk(2.0) mesh is a closed (volume) 3D surface Mesh, and inserting particle is small enough, but why there are so many errors? (please take a look at the attached vtk mesh)
So could you please give me an example of "real" legacy VTK file?
Kind regards,
David
Hi David,
Hi David,
it's VTK2 txt files containing only VTK_TETRA elements, see
http://www.vtk.org/VTK/img/file-formats.pdf
>> And how to make/convert STL mesh to this type of mesh?
That's something I don't know
Cheers
Christoph
convert it with TetGen
A very good tool to convert stl to volume vtk is tetgen:
http://wias-berlin.de/software/tetgen/tetgen143.html
and than:
tetgen body.stl -K
will produce a nice body.1.vtk which you can import with mesh/tet
best,
Christian.
How to convert stl to vtk?
I'm new, and I'm really at a loss as to how to transform files. I tried Christoph program, but I failed to use the program.
Kind regards
Guillermo
tetgen -h
in unix you can often help your self with man PROGRAMMNAME or PROGRAMMNAME -h
I can realy better help you when you provide some outputinfo, the mesh itself and the things you allready tried. (edit: ok I found a mesh in the initial question, but from keepfit ..).
Keep in mind that it may be impossible to generate a volume out of a unclosed surface mesh because the programm can not know where the tetraeder should start and end.
A good idea is to start with a simple testcase.
Create a Source->Box in paraview, Save Data as VTK***. (this will result in a SURFACE mesh, because for PV a box consits of six quadratic planes and not of two tetrateder ! so from vtk point of view it is a surface and not a volume).
Than tetgen the box.vtk .(this should produce a volume mesh you can use in liggghts).
When this works you can make the body more complex (add a source->Zylinder, Fiter->append datasets, save & tetgen) ..
when you are familar with the procedure you can start using a complex volume made by CAD or whatever.
edit: I downloaded the tar archive and run it with tetgen 1.5.1. beta. Something seems wrong with the mesh, I got only 0 tets generated. I remeshed it with gmsh to a STL file to make sure only triangles are in it.
gmsh -2 -o file.stl file.vtk #means: mesh 2D -output file.STL input file.VTK
and that used
tetgen -k file.stlresult:
dem@T7611:~/sandbox$ /home/dem/Downloads/tetgen1.5.1-beta1/tetgen -k file.stl
Opening file.stl.
Delaunizing vertices...
Delaunay seconds: 0.04
Creating surface mesh ...
Jettisoning redundant points.
Surface mesh seconds: 0
Constrained Delaunay...
Constrained Delaunay seconds: 0
Removing exterior tetrahedra ...
Exterior tets removal seconds: 0
Optimizing mesh...
Optimization seconds: 0
Writing file.1.node.
Writing file.1.ele.
Writing file.1.face.
Writing file.1.edge.
Writing file.1.smesh.
Writing file.1.vtk.
Output seconds: 0.03
Total running seconds: 0.07
Statistics:
Input points: 9216
Input facets: 3072
Input segments: 4566
Input holes: 0
Input regions: 0
Mesh points: 1709
Mesh tetrahedra: 5709
Mesh faces: 13125
Mesh faces on exterior boundary: 3414
Mesh faces on input facets: 3414
Mesh edges on input segments: 4737
Steiner points on input segments: 171
And now opening the file in PV, create new view spreadsheet, select Attribute->cell Data and tada: Cell type is Tetrahedron
you can DL the result here:
http://www.richtisoft.de/transfer/surface2volume.zip
I would be happy about a small donation to christian@richtisoft.de for solving this issue for you.
Best Christian
***It is not a good idea to store STL from PV-sources, because the writer only exports half of the mesh because of a bug, in 4.3.1 you simply can not export quad elements to stl.
Hi all!
Hi all!
I tried to use the region mesh/tet command for particle generation. However, an error already occurs when LIGGGHTS is reading the VTK file:
Note: Skipping empty line in VTK Mesh file
Note: Skipping empty line in VTK Mesh file
Note: Skipping empty line in VTK Mesh file
Note: Skipping empty line in VTK Mesh file
ERROR on proc 1: unrecognized (../region_mesh_tet.cpp:591)
I have generated the VTK file using tetgen as explained above. The command I used to create the region is:
region Vol mesh/tet file mesh/Volume.1.vtk scale 0.001 move 0. 0. 0. rotate 0. 0. 0. units box
I am running out of ideas how to solve the problem. I appreciate any recommendation! (if some important information to find a solution is missing please just let me know!)
Best regards
Harald
Hi Harald,
Hi Harald,
I am aware that "unrecognized" is not the best feed-back of a code :-)
I would suggest you compare your file structure with the one from the public tutorial!
This should make it clear where the problem is...
best wishes
Christoph