Hi. I have been trying to use six servo-controlled mesh walls to prepare an isotropic sample with a target pressure of 100kPa but encounter an issue that I could not prepare a "stable" sample.
I have 8000 spheres in the granular assembly. The particle size ranges between 1.1e-4m and 4.4e-4m, and the hard_particles is used with Young's modulus of 7e10Pa. Thus a tiny timestep of 5e-10s is adopted, less than one percent of both the Rayleigh time and the Hertz time. During the running, I extract the positions of six walls, based on which the area of each wall in contact with spheres is calculated. This allows me to apply a constant pressure multiplied by the area as the target_val (target force) for the servo-walls. When I use the parameters of servo-walls with kp=0.1 ki=0.0 kd=0.0 and vel_max=10, the target pressure of 100kPa can be nearly obtained after a number of steps, but the void ratio of the sample is still decreasing mildly (like a 5e-7 drop in 10000 steps).
To judge whether the sample is stable or not, I replace the six servo-walls with the velocity-controlled walls and put the velocities as zero, i.e., do not move these velocity-controlled walls. Then I let it run (relaxation steps) but notice the pressure of the sample is dropping (it can drop around 80kPa in a number of steps), signaling that the sample is not stable or ready to use. Since later I will apply constant volume shearing, if I see the reduction of pressure, I do not know whether the reduction is attributed to the shearing or the non-stable sample. I have played the values of kp near 0.1 and vel_max near 10 but could not achieve what I want. I have also used the mode auto but until now I have not got what I want.
Can anyone provide some insights or suggestions into this issue? Your help is really appreciated. Thanks.
Hi
Hi
You can observe the stability of the sample by tracking the KE of the model during the isotropic compression)
I guess you need to do a bit of parametric study related to PID constants with servo-wall velocity to achieve the predefined target servo-wall pressure.
following suggestions might helpful
(1) Calculate the maximum servo-wall velocity (skin/2*delta_t)
(2) And take the servo wall velocity to be 1/100 of the calculated maximum velocity (of course it also depends on the simulation domain and other factors.
I guess it might work for you.
Thanks
Happy working !!
some same problem about your simulation
Hi Ming;
I have the same question about confining stage?
Did you find a method to solve it?
By the way, how to get the void ratio of the sample in confining process?
I also learn the cfdem now.
My email: 201916131103@cqu.edu.cn
Thanks