Dear all,
I am doing a case study shown in tutorials of CFDEM and feel confused about "fix couple/cfd/force" and "fix couple/cfd/force/implicit" commands. The online documentation says the "fix couple/cfd/force" command contains contributions from all force models active in the CFD calculation, while the "fix couple/cfd/force/implicit" seems only contain the drag force coz it says "At every coupling time step the drag coefficient and the fluid velocity is transferred to LIGGGHTS".
I am wondering if I want to exert all the drag force, viscous force, hydraulic gradient force on Particles, does that mean I can only use the "fix couple/cfd/force" including all the necessary forces while cannot use the implicit one which only include drag forces? The example given in tutorial, i.e. cfdemSolverPiso/ErgunTestMPI use the "fix couple/cfd/force/implicit" command, does that incorrect for modelling all the forces on particles? Could anyone tell me the difference between these two commands if convenient?
Thanks ahead!
Rachel
Hi Rachel,
Hi Rachel,
do you get different results if you exchange one line for the other?
Regards,
Andrés
I hope its not too late
Hi Rachel,
as far as I've understood this the difference is that by using "fix couple/cfd/force/implicit" the drag coeff is calculated every DEM timestep (regarding the current U Field) while by using "fix couple/cfd/force" its only calculated after every CFD timestep. I didn't test it yet, but if this is the case then the results should be different if tDEM << tCFD.
Regards,
Ermek