Particles crossing wall

Submitted by rob1 on
Attachment Size
image.png 67.15 KB
image2.png 146.1 KB
rob1

Probably is it due to a bug in LIGGGHTS?
I've read of problems related to particles crossing walls, but I have the latest release and I think these bugs have been fixed.

I've tried everything: timestep, mesh size, particle size, skin.
Can somebody help me?
Thanks a lot.

Wed, 18 Nov 2015 - 16:56 Permalink
JoshuaP

maybe you put a too large force on the particles? what is the pressure on the top plate? ... I saw u put in a negativ value for target val of the top wall. Try to put a positive value and change in axis the 1 to a -1.

Thu, 19 Nov 2015 - 11:32 Permalink
rob1

No, it is not working... I always lost particles like in the picture.
I believe it is a problem of a moving mesh crossing a periodic boundary... what do you think? And is there any solution?

It's strange that it is not possible to simulate a shear cell with imported stl surfaces... what boundary conditions should I use?
Thanks,
rob1

Thu, 19 Nov 2015 - 14:08 Permalink
rob1

It's incredible, I am experiencing this problem (particles crossing stl walls) even without using periodic boundary conditions!
I have used a longer bottom surface and a longer simulation box, constraining the particles between two primitive planes.

Can somebody tell me if this is due to a bug?
I have used different mesh refinements and particle radii...

Thank you,
rob1

Thu, 19 Nov 2015 - 15:48 Permalink
JoshuaP

on your attached figure it looks like that the mesh output and the particle output doesnt coincide on time. do you always clear your post folder before you run a new simulation?
on the left side of your picture is no mesh but the particle stay in the triangle position, so I assume that the mesh is just wrong in the output. Remove all mesh outputs and rerun it.
If nothing works try to build up a new model and post it here again if it is still not working.

Fri, 20 Nov 2015 - 09:20 Permalink
rob1

In reply to by aaigner

Hello Andreas,
Yes I am using stl mesh crossing a periodic boundary.
I don't understand why it does not work... so how can I model a shear cell with a complex surface?
Do you have any suggestion?

Thanks a lot!

Tue, 24 Nov 2015 - 09:05 Permalink
rob1

In reply to by aaigner

I am trying to use different boundary conditions to simulate this shear cell: no periodic boundaries and particles contained between top and bottom meshes, and primitive planes on x axis. See the attached picture! I am losing one entire row of particles!

So this time it is not due to periodic BCs, maybe something regarding elasticity?
I specifiy that I have tried meshes with different refinements (triangle size)...

Thanks again,
rob1

Tue, 24 Nov 2015 - 09:23 Permalink
Riccardo Maione

Hello rob1,

make sure your stl is a good quality mesh, you may look to non manifold points for a start

Regards
Riccardo

Wed, 25 Nov 2015 - 12:09 Permalink
rob1

In reply to by Riccardo Maione

Hello Riccardo thank you for your help.
Anyway, I have already checked the mesh and there are no problems... think that it is not working even with simple meshes (e.g. 2 triangles per face)...

Wed, 25 Nov 2015 - 15:12 Permalink
ckloss

Hi,

not a bug - 99.9% (my guess)
I guess this solves the mystery: Y= 1.0e7 Pa is pretty low...

Best wishes
Christoph

Thu, 10 Dec 2015 - 22:53 Permalink

Hello,
I am a new user of LIGGGHTS and I am simulating a shear cell with:
- upper surface as servo, to apply a force in y direction
- lower surface moving in x direction
- fixed walls in the z direction
- boundary p f f
All the surfaces are imported as STL files.

I have the problem that after the compression of the particles and during the motion, at a certain time some particles disappear because cross the lower wall and are lost from the domain. The same happens even without movement of the lower wall, i.e. simply with a compression.
This is my script, can you help me?!

Thanks a lot
============================================
atom_style sphere
boundary p f f
newton off
units si
communicate single vel yes

region reg block 0 0.01 0 0.01 0.0 0.01
create_box 1 reg
neigh_modify delay 0

fix m1 all property/global youngsModulus peratomtype 1.0e7
fix m2 all property/global poissonsRatio peratomtype 0.25
fix m3 all property/global coefficientRestitution peratomtypepair 1 0.5
fix m4 all property/global coefficientFriction peratomtypepair 1 0.5

pair_style gran model hertz tangential history
pair_coeff * *

fix part all particletemplate/sphere 1 atom_type 1 density constant 1000 radius constant 0.0003
fix distr all particledistribution/discrete 63243 1 part 1.0

fix bottom all mesh/surface/stress file mesh/bottom_triang1mm_sal.stl type 1 scale 0.001 stress on
fix top all mesh/surface/stress/servo file mesh/top_l1.stl type 1 scale 0.001 move 0.0 -0.007 0.0 &
stress on com 0.0 0.0 0.005 axis 0.0 1.0 0.0 ctrlPV force target_val -0.1 vel_max 0.5
fix front all mesh/surface/stress file mesh/lateral_front.stl type 1 scale 0.001 stress on
fix back all mesh/surface/stress file mesh/lateral_back.stl type 1 scale 0.001 stress on
fix geometry all wall/gran model hertz tangential history mesh n_meshes 4 meshes bottom top front back

region insreg block 0 0.01 0.001 0.003 0.0 0.01
group nve_group region insreg
fix ins all insert/pack seed 5330 distributiontemplate distr maxattempt 200 insert_every once &
overlapcheck yes all_in yes vel constant 0.0 0.0 0.0 region insreg particles_in_region 1000

fix integrator all nve/sphere
compute forces all wall/gran/local force_normal force_tangential

timestep 0.0000001

run 5000

dump dmp all custom 5000 post4/dump*.triangular id type type x y z ix iy iz vx vy vz fx fy fz &
omegax omegay omegaz radius
dump dmpstl1 all mesh/stl 5000 post4/bottom*.stl bottom
dump dmpstl2 all mesh/stl 5000 post4/top*.stl top
fix motion all move/mesh mesh bottom linear 0.01 0.0 0.0
fix time all check/timestep/gran 1000 0.2 0.2

run 3000000
===============================================