| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| sc_coord.png | 212.15 KB |
| sc_coord_centre.png | 132.73 KB |
| sc_coord_slice.png | 214.36 KB |
| sc_10per_overlap_coord.png | 162.6 KB |
| in.sc_packing.txt | 1.75 KB |
| sc_packing_zoom_force.png | 131.54 KB |
This probably relates to this problem, but I've posted a new topic to attach some images...
I have just tried to verify the coordination number for some simple packings (in this case simple cubic). I have computed and dumped the coordination number using computer coord/gran. I was expecting a coordination number of 6 everywhere apart from at the edges...
I have attached some images showing the overall cube, and then a cubic clip of the centre portion, to avoid edge effects (there are no periodic boundaries in this sim), and a slice through a larger setup. As can be seen, at the centre the coordination number is zero, and the maximum anywhere is 3 - the average from the log file is 2.7.
I tried playing with the neighbor command - changing this value results in changing "Total # of neighbors" and "Ave neighs/atom" but does not change the values from the compute - which are always in the range 0-3 here.
Is this a bug, or am I doing something wrong?
Regards, Mark
Hi Mark, how did you generate
Hi Mark,
how did you generate the packing - do the particles _really_ touch, i.e. overlap? The compute coord/gran only counts particles that are actually in touch (as opposed to neighbors).
If the lattice spacing is exactly equal to particle diameter, this is probably a round-off issue. In that case, you try a slightly smaller lattice spacing. If the problem persists, feel free to send me the script
Christoph
In reply to by anonymous_stub (not verified)
Still having problems with 10% particle overlaps
Hi Christoph,
I generated the packing with the lattice command - I've attached the script to the original post. I've modified it to allow for a large (10%) overlap, and to make it periodic in all directions. However, I still don't see the expected coordination number - see the new graphic sc_10per_overlap_coord.png.
I've also checked by computing pair/gran/local and zooming to look at one particle (see sc_packing_zoom_force.png) - here the coordination number is 3, but the forces acting with the nearest 6 particles are also seen. Although they are rather small - I'll go back and check the particle parameters (which were copy and paste from an example!).
Any hints as to what I'm doing wrong gratefully accepted!
Thanks, Mark
In reply to by anonymous_stub (not verified)
Hi Mark, thanks for posting
Hi Mark,
thanks for posting the script! seems that this is a bug, I will have a look at it and fix it next week when I am back in office!
Cheers, Christoph